Boston's Seafood Bounty: A Critic's Guide to the Five Must-Visit Eateries

2024-02-25

Dive into Boston's seafood scene with this critic's top picks, from classic chowders to innovative boil bags, each offering a taste of the ocean's finest.

1. Legal Sea Foods - Copley Place

Nestled in Copley Place Mall, Legal Sea Foods entices with an array of delectable offerings, including their renowned oysters and irresistible crab cakes. A local favorite, the restaurant presents diners with freshly caught seafood and boasts an especially warm and delicious lobster roll. The ambiance, cast under a cozy glimmer, pairs perfectly with the New England Clam Chowder—a dish with a fan club of its own. While service may at times wane, a seat by the window, a sought-after spot for its city views, is worth a bit of competition. Prices are reasonable, considering the restaurant's stellar setting and quality fare. As you traverse the mall, ensure you stop by this gem for a quintessential Boston seafood experience—and aim to snag that window seat for an unparalleled view.

Location: Second Floor @ Copley Place Mall, 100 Huntington Ave, Boston, MA 02116

2. Bay Pointe Waterfront Restaurant

Secluded in Quincy, the Bay Pointe Waterfront Restaurant offers panoramic waterfront vistas alongside seafood guaranteed to tempt any Bostonian palate. Their seafood platter deserves acclaim despite the occasional misstep, such as an erratically cooked steak and an uninspiring coleslaw. Nonetheless, the lobster roll triumphs, securing its place among gastronomic legends. Despite a few lapses, like the unexpected self-service takeaway, the overall service shines. The restaurant strikes a balance between refined dining and family-friendly, with ample parking for a worry-free visit. Bay Pointe holds firm as a tempting destination for seafood enthusiasts, and its appeal as a venue for celebratory meals—where the lobster roll takes center stage—cannot be understated.

Location: 64 Washington Ct, Quincy, MA 02169

3. King Crab Juicy Seafood

King Crab Juicy Seafood in Saugus, MA, offers an adventurous seafood boil that has patrons reveling in the copious amounts of crab and shrimp enveloped in delectable sauces. Boasting immaculate cleanliness and attentive service, the establishment makes the dining experience a joy. However, some guests have felt ensnared by obscure costs and a lackluster delivery experience. While a flavor enhancement would benefit the seasoning, vegetarian options like fries ensure there's something for everyone, though the mozzarella sticks may underwhelm. Partake with caution—there have been murmurs of meager portions and questionable freshness. If you're venturing through Boston with a hankering for Cajun-inspired meals, it's worth a stop, but consider dining in and paying attention to the details.

Location: 180 Main St, Saugus, MA 01906

4. Holly Crab Mad For Chicken

Situated on Commonwealth Avenue, Holly Crab Mad For Chicken is Boston's touch of Southern hospitality. Their zestful offerings, including the succulent Boiled Snow Crab Legs and the perfectly crunchy fried catfish, promise to satiate the spice aficionado. Across the board, the food consistently receives rave reviews with a warning to avoid the occasionally overdone shrimp. A unique fizzy lemonade punctuates the spicy feast. Expect stellar service even amid the competitive parking situation. The venue's laid-back setting fosters an authentic seafood fiesta, where bibs and wipes are essential dining companions. Reasonably priced, this establishment is a can't-miss spot for a laid-back, finger-licking gastronomic journey—ideal for those who prioritize flavor over formality.

Location: 1098 Commonwealth Ave, Boston, MA 02215

5. Cap't Loui

With a flair for the dramatic in flavor, Cap't Loui in Stoneham is a splash hit with sublime clam chowder and jambalaya. The boil bags offer a delightfully untidy experience that's part of the charm, especially with children who'll enjoy the basket meals. Service can vary, sometimes falling short on menu knowledge, yet always delivered with a smile. Seafood lovers seeking zest will be at home here, while those preferring milder tastes might wish to look elsewhere. The cost may rise with the tide, so budget-conscious diners should plan accordingly. An additional thoughtful touch is their impeccably clean restrooms, equipped with mouthwash for a refreshing finish. With convenient parking, Cap't Loui is a beacon for those near Boston longing for coastal Cajun delights—it's certainly on my list for a return voyage for more of that seafaring feast.

Location: 101 Main St, Stoneham, MA 02180