2024-03-02
Bite into the flavors of New York with our expert guide to Atlanta's top five New York-style pizzerias, offering a taste of authenticity with a Southern twist.
With its generous New York-style slices, Alessio's Restaurant & Pizzeria in Roswell, GA, is a haven for pizza lovers seeking hearty servings that promise leftovers. The vibe is resonant with a familial buzz, perfect for dining in with a cold beer or a glass of Chianti. On the rare occasion a delivery falters, their service recovery is exemplary, offering compensation with sincere apologies. Although most of the menu receives a thumbs up, their pre-packaged meatballs have been a letdown for some. But their Greek Salad and Spaghetti Meatballs remain show-stoppers. Whether you're a local or just passing through Atlanta, Alessio's is a top recommendation for a memorable pizza experience.
Location: 640 W Crossville Rd, Roswell, GA 30075
Johnny's New York Style Pizza on Dallas Hwy is a snug establishment that transports you to the streets of New York City, not just with its pizza but also with the vibe it encapsulates through trivia nights and live music. Their pizzas and wings don't skimp on flavor, coming in as high-value contenders in the pizza scene. However, rumors of cleanliness concerns and odd ID policy anecdotes for out-of-state licenses have surfaced. These minor aspects aside, it's the taste of the pizza and the lively atmosphere that make this a worthwhile stop. It's perfect for those who appreciate New York-style pizza served with down-to-earth local charm—but remember to bring a local ID.
Location: 3718 Dallas Hwy Suite 1, Marietta, GA 30064
Johnny's New York Style Pizza in Lawrenceville is a spot that aims to replicate the authentic New York pizzeria experience, though it falls short in ambiance due to dated decor and an inexplicably chilly interior. Their pizza, particularly their flatbreads and garlic knots, are highlights that make it worth braving the cold. However, their pricing and occasional takeout missteps could deter some. Despite this, many are willing to overlook the flaws for the sense of community and appetite for engaging local trivia nights. While I have reservations, I’m not opposed to giving Johnny's another visit, mainly for their much-lauded garlic knots.
Location: 3157 Sugarloaf Pkwy Suite 100, Lawrenceville, GA 30045
Johnny's New York Style Pizza in Marietta scores points for its killer New York-style pizzas and friendly service. Although it has its minor letdowns, like a cramped bar space and less saucy pizzas than some would prefer, it’s still a hit for the majority. Modest critiques like the desire for extra salad dressing reflect a loyal customer base's fine-tuning suggestions. Despite some recent negative feedback, Johnny's still boasts a devout following who believe there’s something special in those recipes. For those looking to indulge in a 'best taste ever' pizza, this place will likely see you returning for another slice of their comforting, cheesy offerings.
Location: 2970 Canton Rd, Marietta, GA 30066
Stopping at Romeo's New York Pizza in Johns Creek is like stepping into a slice of New York itself. They're acing the pizza game with crusts that epitomize taste and tradition, while their wings are a revelation, even for the discerning. Offering an impressive lineup that includes a delectable gluten-free option, Romeo's wins over a diverse clientele. Their service is straightforward and efficient, and their highlight— the Nutella pie— is not to be missed. When in Atlanta and in need of a bona fide New York pizza fix, Romeo's is both an obvious and an excellent choice. Don’t miss out— just remember to carry cash for a discount on your dive into deliciousness.
Location: 9700 Medlock Bridge Rd, Johns Creek, GA 30097
