Capital Cuisine: A Critic's Guide to the Top Five American Eateries in Washington D.C.

2024-03-07

Embark on a gastronomic journey through Washington D.C.'s most loved American restaurants, where historic charm meets culinary innovation.

1. Redstone American Grill

At Oxon Hill's National Plaza, Redstone American Grill serves up a swanky setting for those looking for a wood-fired steak or a perfectly seared fish. With its sleek decor and enchanting window views, the atmosphere oozes exclusivity. The cedar plank salmon proves as indulgent as the price tag, which hovers between $30-$50. Despite occasional billing hiccups, resulting in double-charges, the experience shines when service is on point. Bring your appetite for opulence and remember to double-check the gratuity—opt for the braised short rib and your taste buds will thank you.

Location: 155 National Plaza, Oxon Hill, MD 20745

2. The Great American Bistro

The Great American Bistro lies in the pulsing heart of D.C., serving as a sanctuary for comfort food aficionados. Dive into a plate of their signature jerk wings and experience a symphony of flavors that'll have you dancing in your seat. The restaurant's quaint quirks, fueled by rumors of an eccentric owner, contribute to its allure. The eclectic atmosphere is matched with pocket-friendly prices, making each deliciously unpredictable meal worth every penny. For an unforgettable foray into a corner of D.C. that brims with personality, The Great American Bistro is an adventure in its own right.

Location: 1545 New Jersey Ave NW, Washington, DC 20001

3. Jackson's Mighty Fine Food and Lucky Lounge

Jackson's Mighty Fine Food and Lucky Lounge in Reston's Town Center transports diners to a contemporary nod to the 1940s. The ambiance, infused with nostalgia, enhances the charm of comfort food staples that have regulars coming back for more. Celebrated dishes such as the crab fritters and drunken ribeye are just a few reasons why this place resonates with so many. Although occasional critiques point to over-seasoning, the dependable quality of both food and service, like the much-applauded warm bread basket, ensures a justifiable indulgence. For a dash of yesteryear with a guarantee of a mouth-watering meal, Jackson's ably fits the bill.

Location: 11927 Democracy Dr, Reston, VA 20190

4. Commissary

In the heart of Logan Circle, Commissary is a beacon of casual American cuisine and a go-to neighborhood hangout. Known for a top-notch fried chicken Benedict and a kids' menu that wins over the young and young at heart, this place buzzes from dawn to dusk. While not every dish hits the high note—the mahi's journey on the grill could be shorter, and some dishes might miss an ingredient or two—the friendly ambiance and personalized service like the custom kids' smoothie more than compensate. With modest price increases and a cozy setting, it lends itself to both intimate brunches and family gatherings alike. Take note of the military discount, and let's hope the next salad is nuttier than the last.

Location: 1443 P St NW, Washington, DC 20005

5. Martin's Tavern

Entering Martin's Tavern is like walking into a bygone era, with its homely feel and storied past—it's where Kennedy popped the question, after all. This Georgetown staple garners high praise for its studded guest list and classic dishes like the French Onion Soup and the Hot Brown. Guests recommend booking ahead in this popular venue, even as it prepares for refurbishment. Consistently excellent service and memorable meals paint the picture of an essential D.C. dining destination. Martin's Tavern is a must for those looking to add a dash of history to their dining experience, promising an iconic setting and a delectable meal in equal measure.

Location: 1264 Wisconsin Ave NW, Washington, DC 20007